Wednesday, September 16, 2009
Banach's lecture
I think David Banach was saying how in order to be a free individual, a prefect individual, pure.. He was saying how in order to be free we have to be trapped inside ourselves, and that we can only view what we see through our eyes. His wording is really fancy but it also makes sense. With his example about the person next to us sitting down I got to realize how I am not experiencing what they feel, but am seeing them sitting down. I would have to ask them how they feel sitting down in the chair. Human freedom to me is how humans are free. Free to go about their daily lives, free to think how they want, speak how they want, freedom of speech.. The max amount that an individual can be free. Happiness is how one decides to feel, it doesn't always have to b how things make you feel, or people make you feel. When people decide to be free instead of being a follower can be appreciated, even though some people like to know what to do when someone tells you what to do. An example of appreciating freedom can be if you have been in a relationship for a really long time, and you're used to making a loved one happy, but then the relationship ends there is a sad,or happy feeling depending on how the relationship made you feel in the end. Like in a Lily Allen song she says how "[she] feels like she's been let out of her cage". Some couples depend on their other half and spend so much time relying on each other, that they do not learn how to please themselves. We should strive to be our own individuals and decide our own right and wrong for ourselves (within the law of course). I found it weird that I hadn't thought with depth about the topics that I read in David Bananch's lecture beforehand, but that once I was reading I agreed with him. I also felt like the way he was writing about other people's rear-ends was funny and odd, because I was looking at my mom sitting down and trying to just see her and wonder how she was feeling. Sometimes I wonder if we are all on one board game, being moved around by someone more powerful than we are. I'm okay with being quiet and not talking to myself like I was crazy but thinking in my head and creating conversations as if there really were several people in my head. Yet individuals need other individuals, or they get lonely, angry, upset.. My grandpa lives alone, and whenever he is around the rest of my family he talks a lot because he is lonely. Even with a pet, like a parrot to talk to, I think he would be better. Individuals are alone in their experiences and inside their minds, yet they communicate their thoughts and feelings to other individuals.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)

Hannah,
ReplyDeleteI really appreciate how you took what you thought David Banach was trying to say, and connected it to your own life and experience. You used examples from other sources as well as your own life, and that really made your response easier to read, and relate to.
What you said about having to be trapped inside your own body to really understand how you feel about things made a lot of sense to me. We're so influenced by popular culture and the media, that all of our views on everything is altered. In order to truly understand individuality and freedom, we need to look inside of ourselves.
I think you could have organized your ideas into strong arguments, and went a little more in depth about what complete freedom is, because to me that's what the article is really based on.
Other than that I enjoyed reading your post, and look forward to hearing your ideas on other such topics.
Hi Jace!
ReplyDeleteI was sort of thinking out loud to understand what Banach was saying in this part of his lecture. So my thoughts were all jumbled up. I hope it helped you understand his lecture though, because you didn’t write a lot on your own blog.
I agree with you that the media and what is around us influence how we may act. Humans are constantly shifting and shaping themselves to be how others are acting. Yet I feel like we must dig deep inside ourselves to find out who we are as individuals. Which sounds sort of tricky to do, I have to admit.
When I was posting the first post on here I hadn’t learned how to separate the paragraphs yet, so they were all jumbled together.
Glad you enjoyed reading my post, I look forward to reading more of yours in the future.